Header
             Welcome to Brookline Menu Bar


CITIZEN COMPLAINT REVIEW COMMITTEE
 

 

Charge

February 5, 2008

It has been nearly eight months since the “incident at Town Hall” on May 24, 2007.
Despite having a nationally recognized police force and a comprehensive policy on citizen complaints, it is clear that we need to review our practices and procedures and improve them.

The 1987 Report of the Selectmen’s Police Community Relations Subcommittee states:

…More than for any other municipal agency, for a police department, "public confidence" is a critical end in and of itself. Not only does our society cherish liberty and carefully dispense the power to curb it, but, effective law enforcement requires public support….

…A police officer's daily and routine responsibilities are among the most difficult and most critical of all municipal employees. Police work inherently involves a high percentage of sensitive and conflict ridden human encounters. Even the most mundane police responsibilities often relate to people in times of temporary, but high stress….

…"Human relations", "race relations", and "civil rights" are all terms that are, thankfully, commonplace in contemporary public discourse. However, the concepts they embody, both individually and in conjunction with each other, must never be taken for granted. These simple, commonplace terms capture what is most important, most profound, and most complex in the obligations of civilized society. Government at all levels must be forever vigilant to safeguard and perfect these great concepts; when they are neglected, not only are grave injustices perpetrated, but the entire community suffers and is diminished….

Questions concerning the process remain as to: whether the complainant should have more access to the internal review report; who should get an opportunity to publicly comment on the report; how civil service protections for police officers interplay with our procedures; and how a charge is determined. It is very important that we as a community come together and restore public confidence in our municipal institutions and their ability to treat citizens fairly and with respect.

In the aftermath of the investigation and disposition of this incident questions have arisen as to whether our standards for handling citizen complaints can be refined and improved. In addition, there has not been a comprehensive review of the policies and procedures. governing citizen complaints since they were adopted in 1987.

Therefore the Board of Selectmen is appointing an independent Review Committee to make recommendations for improvements in policy and procedures. The charge
includes reviewing, to the extent the Committee deems appropriate, the results of the May incident and of other prior citizen complaints along with best practices in other jurisdictions to determine if there are shortcomings in the current system and how they might be addressed. The review process should include ample opportunities for public comment.

The Board of Selectmen, further charges the Citizen Complaint Review Committee to review the citizen complaint policies and procedures of the Brookline Police Department; to examine how those policies and procedures have worked in particular instances; to hold at least one public hearing and to solicit other public comments, as necessary; and to issue a written report to the Board of Selectmen by October, 2008, or earlier if appropriate. That report should include the Committee's findings concerning existing policies and procedures and any suggestions the Committee might have for improvements.
 



 

 

Reports

1987 Original Report of the Selectmen's Police-Community Relations Subcommittee

1998 Community Relations Study

1996 -2008 (through February 2008) Complaint statistics - Brookline Police Department Office of Professional Responsibility

2007 Process for Police Department Discipline and Selectmen's Review

2008 Racial Profiling Prevention Strategies 10 Yr Overview

 

 

 

 

CITIZEN COMPLAINT REVIEW COMMITTEE MEMBERS
 

DEAN K. DENNISTON, JR. 
deandenniston@rcn.com


DOUGLAS LOUISON
dlouison@merricklc.com
 

ELENA FERNANDEZ
fernandez@us.ibm.com

MARTIN ROSENTHAL
martyros@world.std.com

RUTH ELLEN FITCH
refhaf@comcast.net


ROBERT ULLMANN
rullmann@nutter.com

BERNARD GREENE
Bwgreene2001@yahoo.com


DR. ED K. WANG
ediversity@aol.com

PATRICK J. KING
pking@jamsadr.com




 
 
 
Meeting Schedule

Wednesday, February 27, 2008 6pm, at Hunneman Hall in the Main Library
Thursday, March 27, 2008 at 6:00pm at the Old Lincoln School, 1st Floor Cafeteria 6pm
Wednesday, April 9th, 2008 at 6:00pm at the Old Lincoln School, Room 202
Wednesday, April 30, 2008 at 7:00 p.m., PUBLIC HEARING, Old Lincoln School Auditorium
Wednesday, May 21, 2008 at 7:00 p.m. at the Old Lincoln School, Room 202
Thursday, June 19, 2008 at 6:00 p.m. at the Old Lincoln School, Room 202.


 

 

Minutes
03/27/2008 Citizen Complaint Review Committee Minutes

02/27/2008 Citizen Complaint Review Committee Minutes